As always, we are cash and check only, no credit cards.

A bowl of mashed potatoes topped with chunks of roast beef, chopped green herbs, and a golden brown breaded croquette, served in a creamy gravy.

The Orto Experience

At Orto, we strive to transport our guests to the heart of authentic Italian-American cooking. We craft rustic, soul-satisfying dishes from the freshest local ingredients, all served within our historic Miller Place home. We strive to be a cornerstone of the community, celebration, and connection.

Restaurant dining room with white tablecloths, wooden chairs, wall art, wall-mounted lights, and a large window/door with wooden framing.
Elegant restaurant interior decorated for a meal with white tablecloths, glasses, and silverware, featuring exposed brick walls, large windows, and a chandelier hanging from a wooden ceiling.
Interior of a cozy restaurant with white tablecloths, wooden chairs, and rustic decor including a stone fireplace, wooden beams, and wall-mounted lamps.

Our Space

The interior of our historic building offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere, perfect for casual dining, special occasions, as well as dates.

Plate of creamy pasta with grated cheese in a restaurant kitchen with chefs in white uniforms working in the background.

Fresh Pasta

All of our pastas are made in house by our chefs. We offer a range of pastas served in dishes cooked with fresh, seasonal ingredients.

Interior of a cozy bar with a wooden counter, bottles of liquor on shelves, hanging pendant lights, and a reflection in a mirror showing more of the bar area.

The Bar

Our bar provides a casual dining experience with the full menu available. It’s walk-in only with no reservation required. Seating is first-come, first-served, making it a great choice for last-minute dining. And our full wine list and drink menu are available throughout the restaurant!

Black silhouette of a flower with three buds, one large and two smaller, with leaves on a white background.

See our gallery to view more photos and or our menu to see what seasonal dishes we are currently serving.